National Information Centre for European Research

Back

Czech research is making steady progress in ERC competitions. Will national research policy keep pace?

19/11/2026

Czech research has once again attracted the attention of the European news outlet Science|Business, this time for a less encouraging reason. It is particularly disappointing that the story concerns a programme supporting research excellence. An article entitled “Czech scientists call for ERC near-miss grants to continue”, published on 18 November 2026 [1], highlights the uncertain future of ERC CZ, a national funding scheme that supports outstanding research proposals which received high scores in European Research Council (ERC) evaluations but did not secure ERC funding.

Established in 2012, ERC CZ provides an important complement to the European grant system. It funds proposals that have undergone the ERC's rigorous international peer-review process but were not selected for funding because of budget constraints. The scheme gives researchers an opportunity to pursue their research ideas, develop their teams and potentially apply again for an ERC grant. One of its main strengths is that it builds on the results of the ERC's international evaluation process, avoiding the need to establish a comparable national review system.

However, the draft Czech state budget for 2027 contains no funding for a new ERC CZ call. Projects already approved are expected to continue, but the programme's future remains uncertain. The Czech Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports recognises the programme's importance and sought funding for its continuation. If the necessary resources cannot be secured, ERC CZ could gradually come to an end once existing projects have been completed.

The prospect of the programme being discontinued has raised considerable concern within the Czech research community. Researchers and research organisations have emphasised its contribution to excellent research, the quality and independence of the ERC's international peer-review process, and the potential implications for the international competitiveness of Czech research. Proposals have also been put forward to revise the scheme's conditions rather than discontinue it.

What makes this uncertainty particularly striking is its timing. Czechia has been making gradual progress in ERC competitions over the longer term. While the success rates of proposals submitted through Czech host institutions were very low under the Seventh Framework Programme (FP7), they improved considerably under Horizon 2020, particularly for grants aimed at early-career and mid-career researchers. Trends across individual grant categories have been less consistent under Horizon Europe so far, but the overall improvement compared with the early years of Czech participation in the ERC is clear [2].

This progress does not mean, however, that Czechia has overcome its longstanding structural weaknesses. In Horizon Europe ERC calls between 2021 and 2023, proposals submitted through Czech host institutions had a success rate of approximately 9%, compared with a European average of more than 15% [3]. A chart published by Science|Business, showing cumulative ERC success rates by country of host institution for 2007–2024, puts Czechia at around 7%, broadly in line with Finland and Italy [1]. This remained well below the approximately 19% recorded by countries such as Switzerland and Israel [1]. At the same time, researchers from Czechia recorded the highest success rate among European countries in the 2024 ERC Consolidator Grant call [1]. This was an exceptional result in a single call, however, and should not in itself be taken as evidence of a sustained trend. Overall, the longer-term improvement is clear, but so is the considerable scope for further progress.

Analyses by Technology Centre Prague (TC Prague) also show that Czech participation in the ERC cannot be assessed solely by counting awarded grants or looking at the results of individual calls. It is equally important to consider application activity, proposal success rates, differences between grant categories and scientific domains, and the capacity of research institutions to provide an environment conducive to excellent research.

From this broader perspective, Czech research is moving in a positive direction, although progress remains uneven. While proposal success rates have improved over the longer term, the relative level of ERC application activity associated with Czech host institutions has largely stagnated. Insufficient application activity therefore remains one of the structural weaknesses of the Czech research system [2].

Differences also persist across ERC grant categories. The most encouraging developments have been observed among younger researchers, particularly in Starting Grants. Trends in Consolidator Grant success rates are less clear-cut, although Czech participation in this category has expanded over the longer term. By contrast, application activity in Advanced Grants, aimed at established research leaders, remains low, as does the number of grants awarded. Progress also varies between scientific domains. Particularly notable improvements have been recorded in Life Sciences, while greater challenges remain in other areas [2], [4].

These trends have important implications for the future of Czech research. They suggest that a stronger generation of researchers is emerging, increasingly capable of competing internationally. At the same time, they underline that building research excellence is a long-term process. Success in a single grant competition does not necessarily mean that a researcher or their institution has the conditions needed to remain internationally competitive over time.

The research environment may also play an important role. Analyses of ERC applicant mobility show that researchers born in Czechia who submit proposals through host institutions abroad achieve higher success rates than their counterparts applying through institutions at home [5]. It is also worth noting, however, that an analysis published in 2024 found the success rate of domestic applicants applying through Czech host institutions to be the highest among the so-called Widening countries [3].

Czech research institutions also attract a relatively substantial number of ERC applicants from abroad, but proposals submitted by these applicants are less frequently converted into funded grants. These differences cannot automatically be attributed to the quality of host institutions. They may also reflect differences in the composition of applicant groups, researchers' experience and other factors that cannot be reliably disentangled using the available data [5], [6].

Nevertheless, the findings suggest that, alongside individual scientific excellence, institutional conditions may matter: the quality of the research environment, experience in preparing competitive proposals, access to specialist support and the broader conditions for developing research teams. Success in ERC competitions is therefore not solely a matter of individual researchers. It also raises questions about the environment that the Czech research system can offer them.

Czechia has made substantial progress in this area over the past decade. Advisory services, mentoring, institutional support and national funding instruments have all developed. The results of these sustained efforts are beginning to be reflected in the growing international competitiveness of researchers working within the Czech research system.

ERC CZ forms part of this wider support framework. Its value lies not only in providing funding for highly rated proposals that could not be supported from the ERC budget. It also helps maintain continuity in high-quality research, supports the development of research teams and creates opportunities for subsequent participation in European grant competitions. It would, of course, be inappropriate to claim that ERC CZ is the sole or decisive reason for Czechia's improving ERC performance. It is, however, one component of the support environment that has been developed over recent years.

There is also empirical evidence concerning the research outputs of ERC CZ itself. A bibliometric comparison published in the journal ECHO, covering 30 ERC CZ projects from 2012–2021, found that their publication performance was comparable to that of ERC projects implemented under Horizon 2020 with the participation of Czech institutions. In terms of field-normalised citation impact, publications from ERC CZ projects did not perform less well, although they showed a somewhat lower level of international collaboration [7].

This finding is particularly relevant to the current debate. ERC CZ is not simply a scheme offering a second chance to applicants whose proposals were not funded by the ERC. The available evidence indicates that, at least within the sample examined, ERC CZ projects produced scientific publications of comparable quality to those generated by Horizon 2020 ERC projects involving Czech institutions.

The assessment covers only part of the programme's history and does not capture every dimension of its scientific contribution. Nevertheless, it provides an important empirical basis that should not be overlooked when considering the future of ERC CZ.

Extended until 2032, but no funding for the next call

The situation is all the more remarkable because the extension of ERC CZ until 2032 was approved in 2023. As reported by the Czech research news portal VědaVýzkum.cz, this decision was informed by a favourable interim evaluation, which described ERC CZ as a unique instrument for supporting research of internationally competitive quality, with no equivalent in the Czech funding system. Nearly CZK 1.6 billion in total funding had been envisaged for the period 2024–2032 [8].

Yet funding for a new call is now missing. Nor is ERC CZ an isolated case. According to the budget documents, targeted research funding provided by the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports outside the Jan Amos Komenský Operational Programme is set to fall by approximately 65%, or CZK 1.35 billion, year on year in 2027. The funding shortfall also threatens the launch of the EXCELENCE and STRATE programmes.

The scale of this reduction makes clear that the uncertainty surrounding ERC CZ is part of a broader budgetary problem. The absence of funding for a new call does not, in itself, mean that the programme has ceased to serve its purpose or that its benefits have been called into question by expert assessment. Indeed, the ministry has confirmed that it sought the necessary funding during the preparation of the budget.

From a research policy perspective, this raises a fundamental question: How can continuity in long-term research policy priorities be maintained when funding decisions are made through annual budget negotiations? This is particularly important for frontier research, where the benefits of public investment often take many years to become apparent.

It is entirely legitimate to discuss the cost of ERC CZ, the design of the scheme and its long-term financial sustainability. As the quality of Czech ERC proposals improves, the number of highly rated proposals that narrowly miss out on European funding may also increase. This could, in turn, place growing demands on the national scheme. Such developments, however, would provide grounds for carefully reviewing its rules rather than automatically scaling it back.

Existing analyses already provide a reasonably comprehensive picture of long-term trends in Czech ERC participation, the composition of the grant portfolio, applicant activity and success rates, and the scientific outputs of ERC CZ. Although no research policy evaluation can capture every aspect of a programme, the favourable interim assessment from 2023 and the available bibliometric findings provide relevant evidence for decisions about its future [7], [8]. Moreover, Technology Centre Prague has systematically analysed Czech participation in the ERC for many years, examining its development, strengths and weaknesses and, in some cases, the research outputs of funded projects.

The question, then, is how well we use what we already know to make decisions about long-term research policy priorities.

There is still time to find a solution

Over recent years, Czechia has invested considerable effort in building a support system for participation in ERC competitions. The benefits of that effort are beginning to emerge, even though long-term analyses continue to highlight low application activity in some grant categories, uneven trends in success rates and persistent weaknesses in the research environment.

Maintaining continuity in this support is therefore important. ERC CZ is not the only instrument contributing to the progress achieved so far, but it is a significant part of the wider system. Weakening the scheme would not simply affect the funding of individual projects. It would also send a signal about the stability and predictability of Czech support for excellent research.

On 22 October 2026, the Czech Chamber of Deputies allowed the draft 2027 state budget to proceed to its second reading [8]. The budget process also provides an opportunity to find a solution that would allow ERC CZ to continue while leaving room for an informed discussion about its long-term sustainability and possible adjustments. The achievements of Czech research, the programme's evaluation and the analyses produced by Technology Centre Prague offer a substantial evidence base for such a discussion, grounded in the long-term needs of the Czech research system.

Czech research is becoming increasingly competitive at European level. It would be paradoxical if, just as the results of years of sustained effort are beginning to emerge, the support system that helped make this progress possible were weakened.

Daniel Frank, TC Prague, frank@tc.cz, 19/11/2026

The views and opinions expressed above are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of the author's employer.

References

[1] Science|Business (18 November 2026). Czech scientists call for ERC near-miss grants to continue. In English.

[2] Frank, Daniel (2024). ERC – the activity and success rate of the Czech Republic is insufficient in the long term. However, the situation is slowly improving, mainly thanks to younger researchers. Technology Centre Prague, Horizon Europe Portal, 13 May 2024. In English.

[3] Frank, Daniel (2024). Czechia continues to lag behind in ERC grant success rates. Technology Centre Prague, Horizon Europe Portal, 30 September 2024. Original article in Czech; title translated for this reference list.

[4] Frank, Daniel (2025). ERC grants in Czechia 2007–2025: development and trends. Technology Centre Prague, Horizon Europe Portal, 22 December 2025. English overview. The full Part 1 analysis, How the Czech ERC portfolio is growing: grant types, domains and gender, is available in Czech.

[5] Frank, Daniel (2026). Czechia attracts more foreign ERC applicants under Horizon Europe than Poland, Hungary and Slovakia combined. Technology Centre Prague, Horizon Europe Portal, 25 May 2026. English summary of the full analysis, Mobility and success rates of ERC grant applicants from three perspectives, available in Czech.

[6] Frank, Daniel (2026). Where do ERC applicants go, and what does their mobility reveal about research attractiveness? Technology Centre Prague, Horizon Europe Portal, 7 July 2026. English overview; detailed analysis available in Czech.

[7] Vaněček, Jiří; Frank, Daniel (2022). Do ERC CZ projects produce publications of comparable quality to ERC projects under FP7 and Horizon 2020 implemented at Czech institutions? ECHO, issues 5–6/2022, Technology Centre Prague. Original publication in Czech; title translated for this reference list.

[8] Vojtíšková, Vladislava (2026). ERC CZ under threat: No funding for the next call, experts warn of a strategic mistake. VědaVýzkum.cz, 27 October 2026. Original article in Czech; title translated for this reference list.

 

More

European Commission publishes a new version of the AGA

18/11/2026

The European Commission has published version 3.0 of the Annotated Grant Agreement (AGA). The AGA explains the provisions of the EU Model Grant Agreement and provides practical guidance and examples. The new version is dated 1 November 2026 and follows version 2.0, published...

CZEDER 2026: From Stated Priorities to Strategic Choices in Preparing for FP10?

16/11/2026

Preparations for the next EU Framework Programme for Research and Innovation are entering a new phase. Alongside discussions about the future of European research funding, an important question is emerging: which priorities does the Czech Republic really want to pursue,...

EIT Regional Innovation Scheme Activity Report 2025

15/11/2026

The European Institute of Innovation and Technology (EIT) has published the EIT Regional Innovation Scheme (RIS) Annual Activity Report 2025. The report highlights strong progress in strengthening regional innovation ecosystems, with supported ventures attracting €579 million...

You might be interested in

Project A to Z

Evaluation of Framework Programmes

Legal and Financial Aspects

Support to coordinators

Framework Programme 2028 - 2034